Insurance payments for healthcare services have been declining for a while now, which means providers in all disciplines are looking for ways to optimize their payer mix in order to maximize their revenue. If you haven’t yet calculated the cost of providing your services—and compared that number to the payments you’re receiving to ensure you’re actually making enough money to not only cover those costs, but also turn a profit—then you should. But the question remains: should practices go full-tilt cash-based, remain loyal to commercial and/or government payers, or accept a combination of all three? Here’s what WebPT learned from its most recent rehab therapy industry survey (you can download the full survey report  here) as well as some factors to consider when making your own payer mix decision:

PT Billing Secrets: 5 Things Payers Don’t Want You to Know - Regular BannerPT Billing Secrets: 5 Things Payers Don’t Want You to Know - Small Banner

Most organizations have a fairly even split between commercial and government payers.

As you can see below, the majority of organizations surveyed operate on a fairly even split between commercial insurance and government payers. A much smaller percentage of providers accept mostly commercial payers, a mix of cash and other payers, or mostly government payers. And few accept only cash or only commercial payers. In other words, most practices are still relying heavily on third-party payers.

Organizations By Payer Mix

There’s also a fairly even distribution of payer mixes across revenue segments—with two exceptions.

Now, as the report shows, when it comes to annual gross revenue, “there’s a fairly even distribution of payer mixes across all revenue segments”—until you get to the cash-only and commercial payer-only segments, which are “dominated by providers with a gross annual revenue of less than $100,000.”

Annual Gross Revenue By Payer Mix

Cash-based organizations are often run by single providers.

We’re not sure why this distribution exists in the commercial-payers-only segment—perhaps it’s simply due to this segment’s small sample size—but it does make sense in the cash-only group, because (as you’ll see in the graphs below), “cash-based entities account for 18.4% of single-provider organizations but do not represent more than 2.4% of any other provider segment.”

Payer Mix By Provider Segment

In other words, many cash-only practices are run by single providers—more than half of whom make less than $100,000 in annual gross revenue.

Annual Gross Revenue By Number of Providers

There’s no one-size-fits-all payer mix.

As you can see, there is not one “right” answer as to the best payer mix for a given practice, but there are some interesting trends. For example, it appears that compared to single-provider practices, larger practices are more likely to accept an even split between commercial third-party payers and government payers (e.g., Medicare and Medicaid). However, that is still the most popular payer mix type for practices of all sizes—although it’s not totally clear whether that arrangement is popular because that’s the way it’s always been done, or because it actually generates the most revenue. Single-provider practices were also more likely to operate using a hybrid payer model—that is, a mix of cash and other payers—than any other provider group surveyed. It will be interesting to see how these numbers change over the next few years as cash-based practice models become more popular—and hybrid models even more so. After all, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to rely exclusively on third-party payer reimbursements.

But, there are several factors to consider when making payer decisions.

As I discussed here, before deciding on a payer mix, providers should consider several factors, including how much risk they’re willing take as well as their geographic area, referral sources, and overhead costs—not to mention patient demographics. After all, some patients simply may not be comfortable paying for your services out of pocket, even if they receive reimbursement from their insurance company. And some referral sources may only be willing to pass on patients with a particular insurance.

Staying in-network with every payer may not be sustainable.

That being said, keeping an in-network relationship with every payer may not be a sustainable practice—especially if you’re not earning enough money to cover the cost of of a patient visit. After all, going out-of-network enables you to negotiate with the patient directly to establish a price point that works for both of you. That’s not an option you have available when you’re under contract with a payer. According to WebPT President Heidi Jannenga in this webinar, “some providers try to make up the cost difference [of a low-ball third-party payer rate] by either increasing the volume of patients they see or reducing total patient treatment time or care episodes, but none of those decisions are based on what’s best for patients; instead, those providers are making concessions to their treatment plans that essentially reduce the quality of the care they’re providing for all of their patients.” And that’s a slippery slope that could end up hurting your patients—and your practice’s reputation.

But, there are situations in which you may want to remain in-network—even if the fee schedule is less than ideal.

Every decision to drop a payer should be made with caution, because it could cause a drop in revenue—at least in the short term. While hanging on to a payer that requires you to cut corners on patient care is an all-around bad idea, WebPT CEO Nancy Ham believes there are some situations in which you may want to remain in-network with a particular payer, even if the fee schedule isn’t ideal—for example, when dropping that payer could:

  • “prevent some of your current patients from receiving the care they need,
  • “reduce the number of new patients you see, and
  • “cause problems with your top referrers.”

While optimizing your payer mix is crucial to the success of your practice, there are several other things you can do to boost revenue and ensure operational efficiency—thus improving your bottom line. For example, you could focus your energy on improving patient retention and implementing lean business principles. That way, if you need to keep a payer on for any one of the reasons Ham mentioned, you’ll still be in good financial shape.

How do you determine the right payer mix for your practice? What does your payer mix look like now—and are you pleased with it? Share your perspective in the comment section below.

  • Cashing In on Private Pay: The PT's Guide to Going Out-of-Network Image

    webinarJul 27, 2017

    Cashing In on Private Pay: The PT's Guide to Going Out-of-Network

    For many rehab therapists, submitting a claim to a third-party payer feels a lot like pulling the lever on a slot machine. You never know for sure what you’re gonna get—and most of the time, it’s less than you’d hoped for. With seemingly ever-increasing regulations—and constantly shrinking reimbursements—it’s no wonder so many PTs, OTs, and SLPs feel like the financial odds are stacked against them. [video://] As a result, more and more rehab therapy providers are trying …

  • Suppressing Sticker Shock: How to Handle Your Patients’ High-Deductible Health Plans Image

    webinarFeb 23, 2017

    Suppressing Sticker Shock: How to Handle Your Patients’ High-Deductible Health Plans

    Copayments, coinsurances, unresolved balances—oh my! Any one of these can cause headaches for healthcare providers, but as healthcare reform efforts shift more and more financial burden to insurance beneficiaries, today’s practitioners are increasingly facing all three. And these challenges are not only hurting their patient acquisition and retention rates, but also their bottom lines. Tired of spending time verifying benefits only to lose those patients to copay sticker shock? Stuck in a constant cycle of pursuing past-due …

  • Common Questions from Our Patient Sticker Shock Webinar Image

    articleMar 31, 2017 | 33 min. read

    Common Questions from Our Patient Sticker Shock Webinar

    From copays and deductibles to payer contracts and benefits verification, understanding all the nuances of third-party insurances is tough enough for healthcare providers—let alone their patients. In WebPT’s most recent webinar— Suppressing Sticker Shock: How to Handle Your Patients’ High-Deductible Health Plans —co-hosts Heidi Jannenga, PT, DPT, ATC/L, the cofounder and president of WebPT, and WebPT CEO Nancy Ham provided a lot of great advice on how to have productive conversations about healthcare costs with your patients—without …

  • Fee for All: How to Set a Rate Schedule for Your Rehab Therapy Practice Image

    articleMay 3, 2017 | 6 min. read

    Fee for All: How to Set a Rate Schedule for Your Rehab Therapy Practice

    I’m going to be frank here: setting the right fee schedule for your clinic is important—like, really, really important. Why is it such a big deal? The answer might seem obvious, but it’s actually a bit more nuanced. When new patients step into your office, you’re not just improving their day-to-day function—you’re showing them the value of their health and well-being. By seeking out movement-based therapy, patients are making an investment in their physical welfare. So, as …

  • Verification Vexation: What to Do When You Can't Get a Hold of a Payer Image

    articleJun 16, 2017 | 5 min. read

    Verification Vexation: What to Do When You Can't Get a Hold of a Payer

    Unless you’re a character in a teen movie from the ’90s , you probably don’t love hanging out on the phone all day. But even the average teenager would undoubtedly agree there’s a better way to spend your time than sitting on the phone with an insurance payer. I know—getting in touch with insurance payers can be a huge pain. Between scheduling, data entry, and collecting patient forms and payments, there’s not a whole lot of time …

  • 4 Major RCM Killers (and How to Fend Them Off) Image

    articleMay 17, 2017 | 6 min. read

    4 Major RCM Killers (and How to Fend Them Off)

    As the old adage goes, your best offense is a good defense—and no one knows that better than the folks responsible for revenue cycle management (RCM). When it comes to rehab therapy billing, getting dinged with claim denials might seem inevitable. But, taking steps to avoid the following four RCM killers will help you shield your practice from taking a critical hit. 1. Ineffective (or Non-Existent) Payment Policy Money talks , and when we’re talking money, there’s …

  • When Patients Can't Pay: The How and Why of Financing Programs Image

    articleMar 13, 2019 | 5 min. read

    When Patients Can't Pay: The How and Why of Financing Programs

    Most patients— especially those with whom your practice has a good rapport —want to pay their bills. Unfortunately, with the rise of high-deductible healthcare plans , patients are now responsible for a larger portion of their healthcare bills (in addition to insurance plan premiums). As a result, many well-intentioned people are simply unable to cover the cost of the care they need. This problem is exacerbated for specialities like rehab therapy, because patients typically need to attend …

  • 9 Questions to Ask a Potential Billing Software Vendor Image

    articleMay 30, 2017 | 7 min. read

    9 Questions to Ask a Potential Billing Software Vendor

    The consumer landscape has changed drastically over the last two decades, and the healthcare space is no exception. Technology has driven much of that change. The rapid pace of innovation has created a technological smorgasbord, meaning consumers can sift through dozens of products until they find the perfect match. This proliferation of options has yielded a fresh set of challenges—including the overwhelming nature of so much choice. Salespeople might be counting on you to make a quick—and …

  • 4 Keys to Keeping a Steady Cash Flow Image

    articleMay 18, 2016 | 5 min. read

    4 Keys to Keeping a Steady Cash Flow

    As a private practice clinic owner, you’re probably familiar with the cold sweat-inducing struggle to keep a steady cash flow. Claims management muck-ups, inefficient processes, staff issues, and lack of insight into your clinic’s financial health can leave you feeling like you’re riding a revenue rollercoaster. So, whether you’re trying to maximize reimbursements , combat employee theft , or optimize patient payments , these four keys to maintaining a steady cash flow will help you even out …

Achieve greatness in practice with the ultimate EMR for PTs, OTs, and SLPs.